aufheben (verb) / Aufhebung (noun)
To negate and preserve at once, lifting something to a higher level; loosely rendered as "sublate," "supersede," or "overcome."
In lecture order, as Marci Shore presents each view. The time opens that minute of the lecture on YouTube.
Aufheben, Hegel's untranslatable verb for how one stage gives way to the next, means canceling something while also keeping it and raising it onto a higher plane.
Put simply Hegel's German verb "aufheben" has no English equivalent. It describes how one stage gives way to the next: the old is canceled, but also kept, and lifted to a higher level.
A line in Zamyatin's dystopia We runs "We comes from God, I comes from the devil": the I is to be overcome and swallowed by the collective.
On Shore's admittedly simplified schema, modernism answers modernity's uncertainty in two waves: a Freudian plunge into the self, then an avant-garde that vaults past it, almost a Hegelian Aufheben.
Put simply Shore, simplifying on purpose: modern art answered the age's uncertainty in two waves. First a Freud-like dive into the inner self, then an avant-garde leap past the self, almost a Hegelian "Aufheben": overcoming something while carrying it forward.
For Kojève, being human means negating the given, in Hegel's sense of overcoming: its concrete features still mark us, but we are no longer its captives.
Put simply Kojève: to be human is to "negate" what is given to us, in Hegel's sense of overcoming it. Its concrete features still mark us, but we are no longer trapped by them.
1 link between claims that both use the term. Each shows the earlier claim, then the later one that answers it. “Our inference” marks a link Shore does not state outright.
HegelAufheben, Hegel's untranslatable verb for how one stage gives way to the next, means canceling something while also keeping it and raising it onto a higher plane. L4 · 35:40
KojèveFor Kojève, being human means negating the given, in Hegel's sense of overcoming: its concrete features still mark us, but we are no longer its captives. L16 · 15:30
Human being as negating the given echoes Aufhebung: overcome yet marked by what it overcomes
Terms that appear in the same claims.