← Throughlines of Modern ThoughtTimeline · Network · Throughlines
A term · 6 claims · lectures 21, 25

Postmodernity

The condition after the last efforts to replace God are given up: no whole, no stable meaning, subject or direction, and general destabilization.

The 6 claims that turn on it

In lecture order, as Marci Shore presents each view. The time opens that minute of the lecture on YouTube.

Lecture 21Power and Archaeology - Michel Foucault

Shore reads structuralism as the final big school to try standing in for God; with postmodernism the attempt is simply given up.

Postmodernity, Shore says, is often defined through its fervent anti-Hegelianism: against Hegel's "the true is the whole," it denies any whole, order, stable meaning, subject or direction.

Put simply Shore: postmodernity is often defined by its fierce rejection of Hegel. Hegel said "the true is the whole"; postmodern thought denies there is any whole, order, stable meaning, self or direction.

Foucault, in Shore's placement, sits on the threshold: no longer quite a structuralist, but not as radically post-structuralist as Derrida.

Lecture 25From Modernity to Post-Modernity

ShoreL25 · 31:15Core idea

Shore reads postmodernism as a late answer to the century's mass killing: a vow of never again that reexamines the revolutionary tradition and concedes something in it went wrong.

Marx wrote "all that is solid melts into air" somewhat before its time: false in 1848, it describes what postmodernism brings about.

Postmodernity, which Bauman names liquid modernity, abandons the search for sturdier solids altogether and welcomes what is fluid, slippery and short-lived instead.

Put simply Bauman calls postmodernity "liquid modernity": people stop trying to replace old foundations with firmer ones and embrace what is fluid, slippery and short-lived instead.

The questions it belongs to

Throughlines that pass through one of these claims.

1 of its claims

Related terms

Terms that appear in the same claims.

replacing GodIn Shore's framing, modernity's central task: God once performed epistemological, ontological, and ethical functions at once, and his disappearance leaves an empty space modern thought tries to fill.
Das Wahre ist das Ganze
the whole / totalityNothing has meaning taken in isolation; only the interconnected whole, graspable only from its end, yields truth.
telosThe end or goal a thing is already developing toward, e.g. the seed is "aiming" at the apple it will become.
linguistic structuralismMeaning lives in differences within a system, not in things; the background that let avant-gardists detach words from referents.
postmodernismA broad current after 1968 that breaks with much modernist thinking and is skeptical of objective truth and of any unifying grand story.
liquid modernity
liquid modernityBauman's term, from around 2000, for the present phase of modernity, in which solid structures melt and are not replaced by firmer ones. He preferred it to "postmodernity"; in the lecture, Shore uses it for postmodernity.